×

INDI Library v2.0.7 is Released (01 Apr 2024)

Bi-monthly release with minor bug fixes and improvements

Failed guide resume after meridian flip and auto focus

  • Posts: 1009
  • Thank you received: 133
Last night my observations had stopped after the meridian flip (yes I know, I should run via scheduler...)

I had a look at the logs, to figure out what happened. I was running a sequence of 200 120s Hα exposures, directly from the Capture tab, with guiding via PHD2.
I used settings 'refocus every 64min' and 'refocus if ΔT>1°'.
At 02:12 a timer-based refocus occurred. Guiding is suspended during AF, as I use an OAG and sometimes the image moves a bit when changing focus direction.
All went fine, including the 20s settle after AF (as the guide star sometimes drifts away from focuser movement)
Right after that, at 02:21, it was time for a meridian flip that started one minute later.
After slewing to the other side, alignment was started. This unfortunately switched my filter from Hα to Red (*)
Alignment went fine without issues, autoguiding was restarted (02:23:57) and the next exposure initiated (02:24:10)
This switched back to Hα, which in turn again triggered an autofocus run :( (I have set AF on filter change)
Also this AF run finished successfully. But when settling after re-enabling the guiding, already after 4 seconds it reported a failed settling, and aborted the sequence.
PHD2 itself needed some 20s to catch the star back and after that continued to guide for the rest of the night....

So I somehow suspect the problem was starting the guiding but immediately pausing it again, leaving it with a large error (some 7 pixels)
I had checked the PHD2 log, and indeed it had reported a settle failure right after the first exposure
Here's the part from the PHD2 log file:
INFO: SETTLING STATE CHANGE, Settling started
1,4.041,"Mount",-5.575,4.081,-5.095,5.074,-2.802,4.059,260,E,315,S,,,989036,489.46,0
2,8.046,"Mount",-3.526,1.777,-3.310,2.420,-1.820,1.936,169,E,150,S,,,1012387,457.94,0
3,12.113,"Mount",-2.078,0.182,-2.045,0.577,-1.125,0.462,105,E,36,S,,,1005718,446.58,0
INFO: Server received PAUSE
INFO: Server received RESUME
INFO: SETTLING STATE CHANGE, Settling failed
4,200.581,"Mount",-6.844,-1.689,-6.988,-0.346,-3.844,0.000,357,E,0,,,,1012080,406.98,0
So PHD2 was interrupted while still settling after the change of the guide star, and likely the settling period timed out during the AF operation.
Not sure who's to blame there - should PHD2 reset the settling state when it gets paused, or shouldn't EKOS send a pause while PHD2 is still settling?

In doubt I attach the logs (kstars and PHD2)

(*) I always disable the filter selector in Alignment and Focus tabs, as I want it to always use the current filter. Unfortunately it is not possible to save this setting, after each restart it is active again. And if I forget to disable that - see above :(
3 years 8 months ago #58054
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Posts: 1119
  • Thank you received: 182
I ran into similar problems the couple of times I did not use the scheduler. I also do not use PHD2. The internal guider was always good, but with GPG algorithm Hy recently implemented, it is dynamite!

I would switch over to that. As is, I just program the scheduler, start it in the evening and then collect my images in the morning. It works like a charm now.
3 years 8 months ago #58067

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Posts: 1187
  • Thank you received: 370
Hi Pit,
I'm not 100% sure but it seems like PHD2 sends a little bit prematurely a GUIDING state. At least the EKOS PHD2 module receives a "Guiding" event while it is still settling during the guiding startup. And while the settling takes place, guiding gets paused but it seems like PHD2 continues to count the time and thus settling fails after pausing is resumed. I would blame PHD2 though :-)

But to really understand it, I need the PHD2 debug log as well. Could you please provide it?

And yes, I think the scheduler would have caught this situation...

Wolfgang
Last edit: 3 years 8 months ago by Wolfgang Reissenberger.
3 years 8 months ago #58261

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.263 seconds