han replied to the topic 'Atrometry.net Offline Solving in macOS Catalina 10.15.5' in the forum. 1 week ago

The ASI533 camera your using has a native resolution of 3008x3008 pixels which would result in a square FOV. But the manual is also speaking of 1920x1080 pixel mode. So the question is which binning mode is used?

Read More...

han replied to the topic 'Atrometry.net Offline Solving in macOS Catalina 10.15.5' in the forum. 1 week ago

wadeprunty wrote: ***A side note: ASTAP works for me like 50% of the time, and that is why I kept working on getting astrometry.net to work offline. Sometimes ASTAP simply times out while solving without logging any specific reason.


With Sextractor & astrometry.net you have a powerful solver.

Out of curiosity and product improvement I like to investigate why ASTAP is not working for you. What binning did you set in Solver settings? See below:


1) For ASTAP you shouldn't bin too much. The resulting image after binning should be 1280x960 pixels or more. So the binning typically should be set at 2x2 in above menu and in the ASTAP menu at 0=auto.
2) An other reason for unreliable solving could be a FOV error. Your screenshots indicated 25.5' x 20.4'. If you load an image in the GUI of ASTAP, is the same FOV indicated in the statusbar of ASTAP?
3) If the exposure time for the image to solve is long it could be that the G18 star database up to magnitude 18 is required rather then the G17. (remove the G17 to force use of the G18)

These causes of poor solving performance can be checked by inspecting the FITS image in /tmp created by EKOS.

In the latest versions of ASTAP some improvements have been added for more reliable solving. Blind solving speed has been increased with about 25% in the latest version 0.9.382.

Han
author of ASTAP

Read More...

Once you have the G18 up to magnitude 18 there is no need for the G17. The G18 will work also for wide field. Inside ASTAP you can configure to use the G18 but the G17 will just take disk space, so best is to uninstall/remove.

I recently added Debian installer for G18. The .290 files from the zip file have to be extracted and copied or moved to /opt/astap

Read More...

Since your using INDI, so Linux I was incorrect about the Astrometry.net version. In Linux you can have the latest Astrometry.net version. But using the correct settings can help like binning or limit the number of objects. Still the online star database of Astrometry.net is better

If your using ASTAP with this small field it is better to use the G18 catalog and remove the G17 catalog. But for these difficult images, Astrometry.net could be better. For ASTAP you can filter out hot pixels with a minimum size or by calibration with a dark but first try it with Astrometry.net since it will be the best change of success.

Han

Read More...

The online solver is better then the older local version (v0.38). The online version has also a better (copyrighted) star database .

The image is difficult to solve. Many hot pixels and poor stars due to long focal length a poor seeing. Maybe also focus. It is possible that the image can only be solved by the online solver. An other reason could be missing index files for the small FOV.


The image is highly oversampled. Both for the image quality and solving a focal reducer could help. An other solution could be to use the guide scope for solving if any.

Han

Read More...

rlancaste wrote: S So I have thought about it for a couple of weeks and decided that the name StellarSolver is close enough and still pretty catchy.

That's much better name. I'm glad you changed it!

Read More...

han replied to the topic 'ASTAP help please' in the forum. 1 month ago

Your image is easy solvable. The setting for solving looks all good now. The only setting to check is the focal length and so on for the correct image size calculation in degrees. This is set as far I remember in INDI driver. Normally I don't work in Linux/Ekos. We can check it using FITS file created by Ekos.

I assume the temporary fits file in /tmp is deleted or moved to the bin after EKOS is closed. Any FITS file created by EKOS will do for checking. If you have a FITS from EKOS please upload it to nova.astrometry.net and provide the link or make a new one (dark) by the button Capture & Solve. The FITS header even from a dark will tell me if the focal length and sensor/pixel size are set correctly. If its too far off (>20%) the solver will struggle to solve.

You could also do yourself. The solved image from nova.astrometry.net tells that the actual dimensions are 0.66 x1 degrees. If you load any unsolved FITS file from EKOS in ASTAP GUI, the ASTAP status bar should indicated the image dimensions 0.66 x 1 degrees (portrait) or 1 x 0.66 degrees (landcape). See below. If not then your settings are not 100%. Is there any reason for the portrait mode?

Han



Read More...

Paul Nixon thanked han in topic ASTAP help please 1 month ago

han replied to the topic 'ASTAP help please' in the forum. 1 month ago

han.k wrote: Maybe you have two problem but lets first solve the solving. There are two binnings configurable. First the one of EKOS:

If you camera with something like 3500x2500 pixels or more set this at 2. If the resolution is less set this one at 1.



Set the ASTAP binning at auto=0



Then can you provide me with one of the FITS images used for solving for testing? You can find a FITS file at /tmp There should be one from last night. Upload it to nova.astrometry.net/ and give me the link or upload it to ufile.io/ and give me the link.

Han



Read More...

han replied to the topic 'ASTAP help please' in the forum. 1 month ago

Maybe you have two problem but lets first solve the solving. There are two binnings configurable. First the one of EKOS:

If you camera with something like 3500x2500 pixels or more set this at 2. If the resolution is less set this one at 1.



Set the ASTAP binning at auto=0



Then can you provide me with one of the FITS images used for solving for testing? You can find a FITS file at /tmp There should be one from last night. Upload it to nova.astrometry.net and give me the link or upload it to ufile.io/ and give me the link.

Han

Read More...

Paul Nixon thanked han in topic ASTAP help please 1 month ago

han replied to the topic 'ASTAP help please' in the forum. 1 month ago

Reducing the binning helps with ASTAP. With Astrometry.net some users have binning at 4x4 but ASTAP doesn't like/compute that. Best would be to set binning at 0 = automatic. The resolution after binning should 1280x960 or higher.

An other thing which helps is ASTAP version 0.9.370 released a few days ago. The star detection routine is rewritten and it's less critical for roundness of stars.

Han

Read More...